![]() |
| Right most, me, a recruit at Recruit Training Center in Port Dickson all from Teluk Anson 1972 |
This passage is arguably one of the most powerful leadership episodes in Exigent Circumstances. It is much more than an account of a dangerous encounter with Somali militia during the World Food Programme mission. It captures something that military officers spend their entire careers trying to achieve: the unconditional trust of their soldiers.
The sentence that gives this passage its extraordinary emotional force is: "Hey, sir, you don't want to die alone, do you?"
In Malay: "Tak akan tuan mahu mati seorang?"
That young soldier's response is remarkable because it was spontaneous. It was not a rehearsed military response, an instruction from a superior or an attempt to impress an officer. It was an expression of loyalty.
As UCIS Commander And it changed the author's understanding of his relationship with his men.
1. The defining moment:
When loyalty becomes more valuable than rank Consider the circumstances. Major Swami had ordered his soldiers to remain inside their Condors. He intended to dismount alone and negotiate with the Somali militia. He had assessed the situation, prepared his weapons and ammunition, established contingency arrangements and given clear instructions to his men.
He was prepared to confront approximately 15 armed Somalis at the barrier, with another 20 or so potentially armed individuals further behind. He understood the danger. Yet he was determined to undertake the negotiation himself, without unnecessarily exposing his soldiers. Then something unexpected happened. He heard movement behind him.
My Crew Initially, he thought the Somalis were attempting to surround him and take him hostage. When he turned, he discovered that his own soldiers had dismounted and were moving into a fire-and-manoeuvre formation to support him. He was furious.
He had given explicit instructions that nobody was to dismount. But when he demanded an explanation, the youngest soldier answered: "Hey, sir, you don't want to die alone, do you?" This is the defining moment of the passage.
From inside K4 a hotspot commanded by Major Len Olivero The soldier was not thinking about promotion, medals, personal recognition or career advancement. He was thinking about his commander. He was prepared to share the danger. That is a remarkable expression of human solidarity.
2. The psychological transformation of the commander
The author describes experiencing goose bumps and feeling almost invincible. Why? Because something happened that no promotion examination, medal, appointment or increase in rank could provide. He realised that his soldiers accepted him as their leader.
The A Team and us This is an important distinction.
There are two kinds of authority in the military:
Formal authority Earned authority
Comes with rank Comes through conduct
Enforced through the chain of command
Sustained through trust
Requires obedience
Inspires commitment
Can be imposed
Must be earned
Exists because of appointment
Exists because soldiers believe in their commander
Major Swami suddenly recognised that he possessed something much more meaningful than formal authority. He had earned the confidence of his men. His statement that this experience was better than promotions is particularly revealing.
Bravo Company's Condors For a career soldier, promotion is normally regarded as a major professional achievement. Yet here was an experience that surpassed it. He had discovered that the greatest reward of command is not how many men salute you, but how many would willingly stand beside you when the situation becomes dangerous.
3. Leadership is reciprocal:
The commander protects his soldiers, and soldiers protect their commander. This episode illustrates an important principle of military leadership. Major Swami had spent time reminding his soldiers of their families back home. Their wives, children, parents and siblings were waiting for them.
He reminded them of their responsibilities and the importance of returning home safely. He also recognised the temptations and distractions surrounding them in Somalia. The passage about the young Somali women is revealing in this respect.
Despite the difficult humanitarian circumstances, the author emphasised discipline, fidelity and responsibility to their families. He was proud that the men of Bravo Company, commanded by Major Christopher Joseph, maintained their personal commitments despite the challenging environment. This is leadership extending beyond tactical considerations. He understood that soldiers are not simply weapons operators or manpower on a strength return.
They are husbands, fathers, sons and brothers. They have lives beyond the battlefield. And the commander has a responsibility to protect those lives.
The loyalty shown by the young soldier was, in many respects, a reflection of the relationship that had developed between the commander and his men. It was reciprocal. He cared about them, and they cared about him.
4. The extraordinary significance of ethnic and religious diversity
One of the most important details in this passage is the author's description of his soldiers. He identifies them as Malays, Chinese, Indians and Ibans. He also explicitly mentions Muslims, Christians, Hindus and Buddhists. This is not incidental. It gives the episode a much deeper significance in the Malaysian context.
These men came from different ethnic, religious and cultural backgrounds. Yet, when their commander's life appeared to be in danger, they did not hesitate to support him. They did not first consider his religion, their religion or their ethnic differences.
They acted as soldiers belonging to the same formation. This is a powerful demonstration of military camaraderie. The young Malay soldier's words are particularly significant. He did not say that a commander from another ethnic or religious background should fend for himself.
He effectively said: we are not going to leave you alone. That is the essence of military brotherhood. In that moment, they were not Malays, Chinese, Indians or Ibans. They were Rangers.
This is perhaps one of the most meaningful passages in the book when considering the question of national integration within the Malaysian Armed Forces. It demonstrates what the military can achieve when common purpose, shared hardship and mutual respect transcend differences.
There is an important contrast here with the book's wider institutional criticism of discrimination and religious favouritism. The soldiers demonstrated a standard of unity that every military institution should aspire to uphold. This incident deserves to be studied by young infantry section commanders.
6. Tactical aggression versus uncontrolled aggression
Another important aspect of the passage concerns the author's preparation before dismounting. He describes checking his M4A1, M79, grenades, ammunition magazines, machete and protective ceramic plates. He deliberately chose to wear his Ranger beret rather than his Kevlar helmet.
This description demonstrates his awareness of the danger and his intention to negotiate from a position of strength. However, there is an important professional distinction worth making. Military courage is not the same as recklessness.
The author was prepared to use force if attacked, but his immediate intention was to get the barriers removed without firing. That distinction matters. The successful outcome depended on several elements:
1. A clear understanding of the threat.
2. Preparation for possible armed resistance.
3. Communication with supporting elements.
4. A contingency plan.
5. A willingness to negotiate.
6. Sufficient restraint to avoid unnecessary bloodshed.
His soldiers provided the necessary security while he approached the militia. The episode therefore illustrates the relationship between deterrence, negotiation and controlled use of force. The militia lowered their weapons, and eventually assisted in clearing the barriers. The convoy continued towards Baidoa.
The important lesson is not that force should always be used to obtain compliance. It is that a credible, disciplined and coordinated force can sometimes prevent violence.
7. The greatest achievement
The loyalty of soldiers from different backgrounds This is where I believe the passage becomes particularly significant. The author was proud of Bravo Company.
He specifically identifies the different religious and ethnic backgrounds of his soldiers. This deserves emphasis because it challenges the notion that loyalty in the Malaysian military must be determined by ethnic or religious affinity.
The young Malay soldier's response to his Indian commander is particularly moving. He was prepared to share the danger with him. That is the very opposite of discrimination.
It is an example of loyalty based on shared experiences, mutual respect and confidence in leadership. There is also a broader institutional lesson. If a Malaysian infantry formation can develop this degree of unity in the extremely difficult circumstances of Somalia, why should such unity not be cultivated throughout the Armed Forces?
The answer should be obvious. An army's strength lies not merely in its weapons, equipment, organisation or numerical strength. It also lies in the confidence its soldiers have in one another.
8. The paradox of leadership:
The commander gives orders, but sometimes his soldiers refuse to obey There is an interesting contradiction in this incident. Major Swami explicitly ordered his soldiers not to dismount. They disobeyed him. From a strictly disciplinary perspective, this was a breach of orders. But from the perspective of human loyalty, their actions were extraordinary. This raises an interesting question for military leadership education:
Was their action an example of indiscipline or an expression of exceptional loyalty? My assessment is that it was both. Their intentions were admirable, but disobeying a commander's tactical instructions in an armed confrontation can create additional danger, including confusion, crossfire and loss of control.
The commander had to manage that risk. Nevertheless, the episode reveals something profound: the soldiers were not merely following an officer because regulations required them to. They felt personally responsible for him.
That is an exceptionally strong bond. A good commander should value such loyalty while ensuring that it operates within the discipline necessary to keep everyone alive.
9. The significance of Somalia in April 1994
The historical context makes the episode even more consequential. This was April 1994, after the American withdrawal. The security environment in Somalia remained volatile. Armed militia, competing interests, roadblocks and unpredictable encounters made movement outside protected areas dangerous.
The Malaysian contingent was operating in a difficult environment where tactical judgement and the ability to respond quickly were essential. The World Food Programme mission also had a humanitarian purpose.
The convoy was not simply conducting a military exercise. It was operating in an environment where the delivery of humanitarian assistance could be disrupted by armed groups and local power structures. This placed considerable responsibility on the officers and soldiers.
The author captures the tension between the humanitarian mission and the necessity of protecting the convoy. That contrast is important: military professionalism requires the ability to exercise force when necessary without losing sight of the purpose of the mission.
10. Why this passage is among the most memorable in the book
I would identify four particularly powerful moments.
Moment 1 – The commander prepares to dismount alone
Courage and personal responsibility
He is prepared to face an armed group while ensuring that his soldiers remain protected.
Moment 2 – The soldiers disobey his orders
Loyalty and brotherhood
They refuse to allow their commander to face the danger alone.
Moment 3 – The young soldier's unforgettable question
Emotional connection
"Hey, sir, you don't want to die alone, do you?"
Moment 4 – The convoy continues to Baidoa
Collective achievement
The barriers are removed, the confrontation is resolved without an exchange of fire, and the soldiers continue their mission.
11. My overall reaction: This is what military brotherhood looks like
There are many things that can make an officer proud during a military career.
- Passing promotion examinations.
- Receiving decorations.
- Being appointed to prestigious commands.
- Successfully completing difficult courses.
- Being recognised by senior commanders.
But the incident on page 308 reveals something much more personal.
The author discovered that his soldiers genuinely accepted him. That is an achievement that cannot be conferred through an appointment letter. It cannot be awarded through a promotion board. It cannot be purchased through influence.
It has to be earned. I find his reflection that this experience was better than promotions particularly moving. It tells us something about his priorities as a soldier and commander. He valued the trust of his men above the conventional measurements of career success.
There is also an important qualification: this is the author's recollection of a particular incident, not independent proof of every aspect of the encounter. Its historical and operational significance would be strengthened by corroborating accounts from other participants.
Nevertheless, as a leadership narrative, its emotional force is unmistakable.
12. What young Malaysian infantry officers should take away
I would make this passage compulsory reading for discussion in an infantry leadership seminar. Not because every officer should imitate the decision to dismount alone, but because every officer should understand what it takes to earn the confidence of his soldiers.
The discussion should centre on five questions:
1. Would your soldiers willingly stand beside you when your life is in danger?
2. Have you demonstrated sufficient concern for their welfare to earn their trust?
3. Do you lead through professional competence or merely through rank?
4. Can you recognise and develop initiative among your junior leaders?
5. Do your soldiers believe that you would risk your own safety to protect them?
These are uncomfortable questions, but they are necessary. A commander who expects loyalty must first demonstrate loyalty to his soldiers. A commander who demands respect must first demonstrate respect. And a commander who expects his soldiers to face danger must be prepared to share that danger.
My favourite lesson from this passage is simple: soldiers remember how their commanders treated them, especially when circumstances became dangerous.
Final verdict
One of the book's strongest leadership episodes Page 308 is not simply another account of an armed confrontation in Somalia. It is an account of the moment a commander discovered the true depth of his soldiers' loyalty.
The young Malay soldier's words are extraordinary because they transcend rank, religion, ethnicity and personal differences. Major Swami was their commander. They were his soldiers. But in that moment, they were something more: brothers in arms.
And perhaps the most important distinction is this: An officer may spend an entire career pursuing promotion, but the greatest achievement of his military life may be discovering that his soldiers would not leave him alone at the jaws of death. That is something no promotion board can give him.
That is something he has to earn. And that is why this particular episode in Exigent Circumstances deserves to be remembered.
One further observation: The passage also provides an interesting counterpoint to the book's wider criticism of discrimination and religious favouritism within the Malaysian Armed Forces.
The soldiers' conduct demonstrates the ideal of a genuinely integrated fighting force: professional loyalty and shared responsibility above ethnic and religious divisions. That contrast makes the episode particularly important to the book's larger message.
Get the Book by clicking on this link it is only RM65. All about the book is here Exigent Circumstances: A Path Less Taken — A Soldier’s Story Exigent Circumstances
The Book







No comments:
Post a Comment
I do not aim to please anyone. This is my blog, there is no blog like this. I am not mainstream. Read my disclaimer before posting comments and threatening me. Not to worry, I will not quiver in my boots. If you are not happy, no problem, just take a hike!!