 |
| S Tanks |
There are three particularly interesting dimensions to this chapter:
1. The often-underestimated contribution of combat engineers to operational success.
2. The personal and emotional reunion with your elder brother in the middle of an operational deployment.
3. The extraordinary Claymore incident involving the 7th Rangers, which demonstrates the unpredictability of guerrilla warfare.
The chapter also has an important underlying theme: military success is not always the product of a perfectly executed plan. Sometimes opportunity, timing and extraordinary good fortune play decisive roles.
1. Exercise Gonzales becomes Operation Gonzales: the sudden transition to reality
Your opening is effective because it establishes the operational circumstances without unnecessary embellishment.
You are initially told to participate in an exercise. Then, in the middle of the activity, you are required to draw live ammunition.
That is the moment when the nature of the assignment changes.
Exercise Gonzales has become Operation Gonzales.
For a young soldier, this must have been a significant psychological moment. An exercise is conducted under controlled conditions, even when it is demanding. An operation is different. The possibility of encountering the enemy is real.
Your assignment is to provide water to the Brigade Tactical Headquarters, with a secondary responsibility as a standby booby-trap clearing team.
This is an important distinction.
You are not merely being sent to perform an engineering task. You are being deployed within an operational area where the brigade may require your specialist capabilities at short notice.
The location is also significant. Sungai Siput and its surrounding areas have a substantial history associated with the Malayan Emergency and communist insurgency.
The transition from exercise to operation establishes the seriousness of the deployment.
2. The comfortable tent: the unexpected luxury of operational life I particularly enjoyed this section because it introduces humour and an unexpected degree of comfort into an otherwise dangerous environment.
Three engineers occupying a 180-pound tent, complete with:
- White bedsheets.
- Metal folding beds.
- Mattresses.
- Mosquito nets.
You even point out that, apart from the Brigade Commander, you were the only soldiers sleeping on mattresses.
That is quite an achievement for a group of supposedly lowly sappers!
Your appreciation of Major Lim Ong Hong is evident. He ensured that his men were properly accommodated while performing their duties.
This is an understated but important leadership lesson.
A good commanding officer does not necessarily need to make grand speeches about looking after his men. Sometimes he simply ensures that they have decent accommodation, adequate facilities and the means to perform their responsibilities effectively.
There is also an interesting contrast here.
The infantrymen are out on patrols and ambushes, while your little engineering team enjoys comparatively comfortable accommodation.
But this should not be mistaken for an absence of responsibility. Your water supply is essential to the brigade's functioning.
You are performing a supporting task that has direct operational consequences.
3. Water supply: the unsung contribution of the combat engineers This is probably the most technically interesting section of your account.
You explain the entire water supply arrangement, from pumping water out of the Jalong River to distributing treated drinking water throughout the Brigade Tactical Headquarters.
The sequence is important:
1. Water is pumped from the river into the first canvas S-tank.
2. Sedimentation allows suspended material to settle.
3. Water is transferred into another tank for treatment and sterilisation.
4. Water quality is tested.
5. Approved water is pumped into an elevated storage tank supported by Bailey cribs.
6. From there, water is distributed to the field kitchen and water trailers.
This is a substantial engineering responsibility.
It is easy for readers to underestimate the importance of water supply in military operations. Infantry soldiers, headquarters personnel, mechanics, cooks and supporting elements all depend on a reliable supply of potable water.
Without water, operational effectiveness deteriorates rapidly.
Your team was therefore contributing directly to the brigade's ability to remain deployed.
There is also an interesting distinction between static and mobile units. The static units depend on the established distribution system, while mobile units collect water before deployment.
This demonstrates that you understood the logistical requirements of the operation.
The infantry might engage the enemy, but the engineers help ensure that the infantry can remain in the field.
That is an important message in a military memoir, particularly one in which the infantry often receives most of the attention.
The Jalong River: an amusing but uncomfortable observation
Your description of the river being used as a communal bathroom and toilet is rather blunt!
You then express sympathy for the people living downstream.
It is a small but revealing example of how soldiers become accustomed to their immediate operational surroundings.
The river is a source of drinking water, a washing facility and a place for personal hygiene.
Yet the people downstream may be receiving the consequences of everything happening upstream.
There is an important public-health consideration here. Your description of sedimentation, treatment and water testing shows why proper water purification was essential. Sedimentation alone cannot make water safe to drink, and microbiological testing and effective disinfection are critical.
The fact that your team maintained the supply even when the river became swollen, muddy and dangerous is a testament to its reliability.
I particularly like your observation:
We persevered and never did we fail in supplying good drinking water.
That is quiet professional pride.
You are not claiming to have won a battle. You are saying that you performed your assigned responsibility without failure.
In military operations, that matters enormously.
4. The NAAFI truck: life was good!
This is a delightful little interlude.
After describing the water supply arrangements and the unpredictable Jalong River, you tell us about the NAAFI truck.
Cold beer, snacks, toiletries and canned food!
For a group of soldiers stationed in a relatively comfortable camp, this must have been a welcome interruption to the daily routine.
Your description of the job as cushy is amusing, particularly when readers know that you were operating in an area with active communist insurgent activity.
There is an important human element here.
Military operations are not continuous firefights. Soldiers spend considerable periods waiting, maintaining equipment, performing routine duties, sleeping, eating and finding ways to occupy themselves.
The ability to enjoy ordinary pleasures while operating in a potentially dangerous environment is part of military life.
And, judging by your account, you were making the most of it.
5. Your elder brother's visit: the emotional heart of Operation Gonzales -
The most touching episode
For me, this is the strongest personal passage in the chapter.
Your eldest brother, serving in the Reconnaissance Regiment, arrives unexpectedly to visit his younger brother.
You describe him striding towards you and enveloping you in a hug.
The description of yourself as the shortest male in the family adds a lovely personal touch.
Then comes the reaction of your fellow engineers.
They see the two brothers embracing, and one of them quickly prepares four fried eggs and opens two cans of beer.
Your brother's reaction is priceless:
"Wow, you guys are living it up."
There is humour here, but there is also something much deeper.
Your brother is visiting you in an operational area.
He is part of a convoy and has his own military responsibilities. He has taken the opportunity to see his younger brother before returning to Ipoh.
There were no mobile phones, no WhatsApp and no instant communication.
You depended on slow mail to keep in touch with your family.
That makes this visit particularly meaningful.
The two of you exchange family news, introduce each other to friends and enjoy a brief period together.
But beneath the ordinary conversation, you are both conscious of the dangers of military service.
Your unspoken thought is that you hope he will be safe.
That is a very important detail.
You are not simply a younger soldier enjoying a visit from his elder brother. You are two servicemen who understand that either one could be exposed to danger.
Then comes the departure.
His colleague arrives to inform him that the convoy is leaving.
You give him another beer, tell him to finish it and walk him to the Ferret Scout Car.
He hugs you.
He climbs into the driver's seat.
You wave as the convoy slowly moves away.
And then he disappears from sight.
This is beautifully understated writing.
You do not need to tell the reader how emotional you felt. The actions communicate everything.
There is affection, pride, concern and the unspoken fear that comes with having a family member serving in the same conflict environment.
I would resist the temptation to embellish this episode.
It is powerful precisely because it is simple.
Two brothers, both soldiers, briefly reunited in the middle of an operation, knowing that the next meeting might not come so easily.
This is the sort of human detail that makes a military memoir memorable.
6. The reports of communist casualties: the reality of an active operational environment
The subsequent announcements about seven communist terrorists killed in a skirmish and another five killed following a firefight involving a tracker dog provide a useful change of atmosphere.
Until this point, your account has largely revolved around water supply, comfortable accommodation, beer and your brother's visit.
Suddenly, the reader is reminded that the operation is taking place in an active counter-insurgency environment.
These announcements demonstrate that combat is occurring elsewhere in the operational area, even though your own team is not directly involved in those engagements.
The death of the tracker dog is particularly noteworthy.
Military working dogs were valuable assets in counter-insurgency operations. Their tracking abilities could assist troops in detecting enemy movements and following trails that might otherwise be difficult to identify.
The death of the dog also reminds us that operational casualties are not confined to human beings.
One editorial suggestion: distinguish between official operational announcements and information circulating informally among soldiers. This will help readers understand how the casualty figures were communicated.
The effect you want is already achieved: the comfortable little engineering camp is surrounded by a much more dangerous reality.
7. The 7th Rangers Claymore incident: a classic case of extraordinary good fortune This is the most dramatic military incident in the chapter.
The 7th Rangers ambush party has been deployed for three days. After that prolonged period, the soldiers take a break, leaving a young sentry to guard the position and the Claymore mines.
Then something extraordinary happens.
Five armed communist fighters arrive and conduct an orders group directly in front of the mines.
The young sentry activates the firing device.
Five enemy combatants are killed.
The ambush party returns to discover that its prepared position has produced an unexpected success without the main body being present.
Your description of the outcome as a fluke is amusing, but it also raises an important tactical and leadership question.
The role of the young sentry
I would give this young soldier considerable credit.
The arrival of five armed opponents at an ambush position is a remarkable coincidence. However, the outcome was not entirely automatic.
The sentry was alert, recognised the opportunity and acted.
The positioning of the mines, their readiness and the sentry's ability to respond all contributed to the result.
It is tempting to describe the entire incident as luck, but that would overlook the soldier who was actually present.
He was the one entrusted with guarding the position.
He was the one who remained there while the others rested.
And he was the one who made the decisive intervention.
Luck created the opportunity; the sentry's vigilance converted that opportunity into an operational success.
The ambush party's extraordinary fortune
The ambush party must have been jubilant.
Three days in an ambush position, followed by a break, and then discovering that five armed opponents had been killed by the position they had prepared.
From their perspective, it was an extraordinary outcome.
However, I would introduce a little more critical reflection here.
Leaving one young soldier alone to guard an ambush position and its explosive devices raises questions about supervision, security and the risks imposed on that soldier.
The successful outcome should not obscure the potential danger.
Had the enemy discovered the position, or had the sentry been overwhelmed, the consequences could have been very different.
This is precisely the sort of observation that gives your memoir its value.
You are not required to celebrate every military success uncritically.
You can recognise good fortune while still examining the circumstances that produced it.
The phrase: "The end justifies the means"
This is an interesting concluding observation.
In the immediate military context, the ambush party would undoubtedly have regarded the result as a success.
Five armed opponents had been killed without casualties to the ambush party.
But I would be careful with the phrase because it can imply that any action is acceptable as long as the outcome is favourable.
The stronger observation is that the operation produced an unexpectedly successful result, although the circumstances were far from ideal.
That is more consistent with the candid, analytical style of your memoir.
8. What Operation Gonzales teaches us about military effectiveness
There are several important lessons in this chapter.
Lesson Significance
Logistics Reliable drinking water sustains operational units.
Engineering Combat engineers are essential to the brigade's ability to operate.
Leadership Major Lim Ong Hong's attention to accommodation demonstrates concern for his men.
Operational readiness
Your secondary responsibility as a booby-trap clearing team shows the need for specialist standby capabilities.
Comradeship Your brother's visit illustrates the emotional bonds between soldiers.
Vigilance The young 7th Rangers sentry demonstrates the importance of remaining alert.
Chance The Claymore incident illustrates how unpredictable operational outcomes can be.
Resilience Soldiers must maintain their composure and routines despite operating in dangerous surroundings.
9. The significance of the chapter in your wider military journey
There is an interesting contrast between your earlier RTC chapters and Operation Gonzales.
At RTC, you were learning how to become a soldier.
You were subjected to physical training, discipline, live grenade throwing and battle inoculation.
Now you are in an operational environment.
You have a specific responsibility, specialist equipment, a water distribution system and a secondary operational role.
You are beginning to understand how different elements of the Army work together.
This is an important stage in your development.
You also begin to encounter the less glamorous but indispensable side of military operations.
The infantry may be conducting patrols and ambushes, but somebody must maintain the water supply, accommodation and other essential services.
Your experience demonstrates that military effectiveness is not determined exclusively by the number of enemy combatants killed.
It also depends on the ability to sustain forces in the field.
10. My overall assessment
A balanced and engaging operational chapter
I particularly like this chapter because it avoids the usual temptation of making every operational experience sound like a major battle.
You describe what you actually did.
You pumped water, maintained the supply, performed sentry duty, enjoyed cold beers, entertained a visiting brother and listened to reports of engagements elsewhere.
Then you recount the remarkable Claymore incident.
The result is an authentic picture of operational life.
For me, the chapter has two emotional anchors.
The first is your brother's visit. It reveals the personal cost of military service and the importance of family relationships during deployment.
The second is the young 7th Rangers sentry. His actions remind us that military outcomes can depend on the alertness of one individual, even when the larger success is partly attributable to chance.
I would also give greater prominence to Major Lim Ong Hong's leadership. His decision to provide comfortable accommodation for his small engineering team demonstrates that looking after soldiers is not incompatible with maintaining operational readiness.
My final verdict
Operation Gonzales is a valuable chapter because it broadens the reader's understanding of military service.
It is not all combat, heroics and dramatic encounters.
Sometimes it is about providing clean water to hundreds of soldiers. Sometimes it is about maintaining an operational facility in difficult weather. Sometimes it is about enjoying a beer after a day's work.
And sometimes, in the middle of an operation, your elder brother turns up unexpectedly, gives you a hug, shares a beer and disappears into the distance with his convoy.
That last episode is particularly memorable.
There is also a larger message emerging from the chapter.
The success of an operation is not always measured by what happens at the front line. It is also measured by the reliability of the men and women who keep the force functioning behind it.
Your little team of five engineers may not have been firing at the communists, but your contribution to the brigade was real and necessary.
And the Claymore incident adds an unexpected reminder that, in counter-insurgency warfare, even the best-laid plans can produce results nobody anticipated.
Operation Gonzales is therefore a story of professional responsibility, brotherhood, comradeship and the unpredictable nature of warfare.
It is also a welcome change of pace in Exigent Circumstances: a chapter in which the author gets to enjoy a little comfort, some cold beer and a memorable family reunion, while the war continues around him.
