
I would highlight several aspects of this chapter.
1. From 19 marksmen to 240:
An extraordinary transformation
The figures speak for themselves.
19
Starting point. Classified marksmen
240
After seven months. Classified marksmen
More than twelve times the original number.
This is an exceptional improvement in the battalion's reported shooting classification.
But the real achievement was not the numerical increase. It was the recognition that the soldiers possessed potential that had never been properly developed.
Swami's observation is particularly revealing:
"All our soldiers like to shoot and do well, it is just that no one has ever taught them how to go about it."
That statement deserves attention.
Rather than blaming the soldiers, he questioned the training system.
This is the mark of a thinking officer.
2. Challenging the culture of intimidation
Perhaps the most important leadership decision was his instruction that nobody should scold or punish soldiers on the firing range for poor shooting.
This was a direct challenge to an established culture.
The traditional approach described in the chapter was to shout at soldiers, double them and make them suffer when they missed targets.
Swami introduced a different philosophy: teach first, correct mistakes and build confidence.
There is a powerful message here:
You cannot continually humiliate people and expect them to develop confidence in their abilities.
He understood that shooting proficiency required instruction, patience, observation and individual attention.
This is transformational leadership in practice.
3. The whiteboard demonstration:
Knowledge creates authority
I particularly enjoyed the exchange between Swami and Lt Col Zulkapli.
The CO pointed to the centre of the square.
Swami corrected him.
It was a bold demonstration, particularly when addressing his Commanding Officer.
But it was not arrogance. He was demonstrating professional knowledge acquired through his Weapons Wing experience.
He was prepared to explain his methodology and defend his proposed training programme.
The distinction is important: authority comes with rank, but professional credibility must be earned.
A subordinate officer who possesses specialised knowledge should have the confidence to share it, even with a senior commander.
4. The coaches: Developing leaders within the ranks
The selection of 25 potential coaches, of whom 18 qualified, was a clever organisational decision.
Swami was not interested in making himself indispensable.
He was creating a network of instructors who could multiply his knowledge throughout the battalion.
This is an important lesson for young officers.
Do not simply demonstrate that you are good at something. Develop others who can become equally capable.
The achievement of 240 marksmen demonstrates the potential of that approach.
5. The unexpected champions:
Clerks, cooks, drummers and a driver!
This is perhaps my favourite aspect of the entire story.
The champions were not exclusively infantry soldiers.
The LMG team came from the clerks and drum platoon.
The GPMG team also became champions.
And the individual champion was a driver from the Mechanical Transport Platoon!
What a wonderful outcome!
It completely undermined the assumption that excellence in shooting belonged only to infantrymen.
The driver demonstrated that talent could emerge from an entirely different military appointment.
The lesson is profound:
Never underestimate people because of the jobs they perform. Give them an opportunity, proper training and a fair assessment.
This is also a story about equality of opportunity within a military formation.
6. The CO's confidence versus Swami's nervousness
The contrast between the two officers is amusing.
The CO was confident. Swami was virtually a nervous wreck.
The man who had spent seven months preparing his battalion was suddenly worried about his own performance.
Then came the cleaning-kit incident.
With a swollen knee, he had to turn back to retrieve his fallen equipment. By the time he reached his firing position, five target exposures had passed.
And then his CO announced:
"Target No 8, zero, zero, zero, zero."
Only to be followed by the actual result:
"Target No.8 zero, zero, zero, ten."
His reply was priceless:
"That bastard would still be dead sir."
I find this episode particularly revealing because Swami does not portray himself as an invincible officer.
He admits his nervousness, physical limitations and carelessness.
That honesty makes the achievement more believable and the story more engaging.
It also illustrates an important distinction between confidence and courage. Courage is not the absence of anxiety. It is the ability to continue despite it.
7. The peacock CO: A proud Commanding Officer
The description of Lt Col Zulkapli strutting around like a peacock is delightful.
He had every reason to be proud.
He had backed an ambitious initiative, trusted his officer and watched the battalion achieve results that previously seemed unlikely.
His words are especially significant:
"Well done Indian! I could not have been prouder."
This is a particularly memorable moment in the book.
For Swami, the acknowledgement represented professional recognition from his Commanding Officer.
In the wider context of the author's experiences as a minority officer, it also provides an interesting example of professional respect and recognition across ethnic boundaries.
The CO was acknowledging achievement, not merely offering a polite compliment.
And Swami's reaction, being on cloud nine, is entirely understandable.
8. The Royal Malay units: A moment of vindication
The description of the two Royal Malay units standing with their eyes downcast adds a competitive edge to the story.
The victory was especially satisfying because 7th Rangers had apparently never achieved this level of success in shooting competitions.
The battalion had finally proved itself.
However, the most important victory was not over the other units.
It was over the battalion's previous limitations and its own expectations.
That is a much more meaningful achievement.
9. The significance of "Well done Indian!"
I would not overlook this particular expression.
Throughout the book, Swami describes the challenges of serving as a minority officer in the Malaysian Army.
There are episodes involving professional frustrations, discrimination, perceived favouritism and questions about recognition.
Here, however, we see a Commanding Officer openly acknowledging an Indian officer's professional contribution.
It is an important contrast.
Swami was given an opportunity to demonstrate his abilities. He delivered results, and his achievement was recognised. It reinforces an important principle: professional competence should be recognised irrespective of race, religion or background.
10. The deeper message: What sort of officer was Major D. Swami?
This chapter reveals five important characteristics:
- Technically knowledgeable: He understood his specialist responsibilities.
- Innovative: He challenged conventional training methods.
- People-oriented: He believed soldiers could improve with proper instruction.
- Determined: He persevered despite scepticism and physical discomfort.
- Results-driven: He converted his ideas into measurable battalion-wide improvements.
One additional quality deserves recognition: he was willing to take responsibility for the outcome.
He did not merely recommend a programme and leave others to implement it. He worked from dawn to dusk, developed the coaches, supervised the training and eventually led the M16 team.
That is ownership.
11. What I would have liked to see more of in the chapter
For an even stronger military leadership account, I would have welcomed some additional information:
- How the 240 marksmen maintained their proficiency after classification.
- Whether the coaching system continued after Swami's departure.
- How the other battalions reacted to 7th Rangers' achievement.
- Whether the Brigade adopted any of his training methods.
- Whether the programme became a permanent feature of battalion training.
These details would help establish the longer-term institutional impact of his initiative.
The technical shooting figures also deserve to be understood within the particular rifle, sight and classification system used at the time, rather than treated as universal ballistic rules.
12. My final reaction A memorable military leadership achievement
I would place this episode among the most positive and satisfying accounts in Exigent Circumstances.
It is a refreshing departure from the more difficult episodes concerning operational adversity and institutional shortcomings.
Here, we see what can happen when professional knowledge meets opportunity, initiative and command support.
There is no need for elaborate theories about leadership.
The results tell the story.
- 19 marksmen became 240.
- 18 coaches emerged from an initial group of 25 candidates.
- Support personnel became champions.
- A driver became the individual shooting champion.
- 7th Rangers achieved a series of Brigade competition victories.
- A Commanding Officer publicly acknowledged the contribution of his Indian officer.
The most important achievement was changing the soldiers' belief in themselves.
I particularly like the author's response to the soldiers who said they had never won anything before:
"There is always a first time for everything."
That sentence captures the spirit of the entire chapter.
It is also a message worth passing to young military officers: never accept poor performance as inevitable. Investigate the reasons, improve the training, develop your people and give them the opportunity to succeed.
My concluding thought: Major D Swami did not merely produce 240 marksmen.
He helped produce a battalion that believed it could win. And when that belief was translated into achievement, 7th Rangers became champions!
Soldiers can be trained. Leaders must use their expertise to bring about the results desired. Never give up on your soldiers. They are your assets